One app for all your study abroad needs
The NCERT Class 11 Political Theory Chapter 7: Nationalism explores the concept of nationalism, its historical emergence, and its role in uniting and dividing societies. The chapter examines how nationalism differs from other forms of collective belonging, the significance of national self-determination, and the factors that foster nationalist sentiments. This section provides detailed solutions to the chapter’s exercise questions, offering clear explanations to help students understand complex political concepts and prepare for exams.
Table of Contents
Explore Notes of Class 11 Political Theory
NCERT Solutions Class 11 Political Theory Chapter 7 Nationalism
This section guides students to clear solutions of Class 11 Political Theory Chapter 7: Nationalism. You can go through the detailed explanation of the subject by understanding the solutions below.
Exercise
1. How is a nation different from other forms of collective belonging?
2. What do you understand by the right to national self-determination? How has this idea resulted in both the formation of and challenges to nation-states?
3. “We have seen that nationalism can unite people as well as divide them, liberate them as well as generate bitterness and conflict”. Illustrate your answer with examples.
4. Neither descent, nor language, nor religion, nor ethnicity can claim to be a common factor in nationalisms all over the world. Comment.
5. Illustrate with suitable examples the factors that lead to the emergence of nationalist feelings.
6. How is a democracy more effective than authoritarian governments in dealing with conflicting nationalist aspirations?
7. What do you think are the limitations of nationalism?
Solutions:
1. A nation is a distinct form of collective belonging, characterised by a shared sense of identity among a group of people who see themselves as a cohesive unit, often aspiring to or possessing political sovereignty. Unlike other forms of collective belonging, such as family, tribe, or religious community, a nation is typically linked to a specific territory and seeks political self-governance. For instance, a family is based on kinship and personal ties, and a religious community is united by shared faith, but neither inherently demands territorial control or political autonomy. A tribe may share cultural practices and a sense of community, but it often lacks the broader territorial and political aspirations of a nation.
Nations are seen as the “imagined communities” (a term coined by Benedict Anderson), where members feel a deep connection despite not knowing each other personally, fostered by shared symbols, history, or culture. This distinguishes nations from smaller, more localised, or non-political collectives, as nations often strive for statehood or self-determination, making them a unique and powerful form of collective identity.
2. The right to national self-determination refers to the principle that a group of people who identify as a nation has the right to freely determine their political status and pursue their economic, social, and cultural development. This idea, popularised in the 20th century, particularly after World War I through Woodrow Wilson’s Fourteen Points and later reinforced by the United Nations, asserts that nations should govern themselves, free from external domination. The chapter highlights its dual impact on nation-states.
Formation of Nation-States: The principle has led to the creation of new nation-states by enabling groups to assert their identity and demand independence. For example, the disintegration of empires like the Austro-Hungarian and Ottoman Empires after World War I resulted in the formation of nations like Czechoslovakia and Yugoslavia, as ethnic groups claimed self-determination. Similarly, post-World War II decolonisation saw countries like India and Algeria gain independence from British and French colonial rule, respectively, as nationalist movements invoked this right to establish sovereign states.
Challenges to Nation-States: However, the idea also poses challenges, as it can fuel separatist movements within existing states. When minority groups within a nation-state feel their identity is suppressed, they may demand self-determination, leading to conflict or fragmentation. For instance, the chapter references the Kurdish population, spread across Turkey, Iraq, and Syria, who have sought a separate state, creating tensions with existing governments. Similarly, in India, demands for autonomy or secession in regions like Nagaland or Kashmir reflect how self-determination can challenge national unity. The chapter notes that such movements often lead to violence or instability when states resist these aspirations, illustrating the complex legacy of this principle.
3. Nationalism has a dual nature of both a unifying and divisive force, capable of liberating people while also fostering conflict.
Uniting and Liberating: Nationalism can inspire collective action and free people from oppression. The Indian national movement against British colonial rule is a prime example, where diverse groups—Hindus, Muslims, Sikhs, and others—united under leaders like Mahatma Gandhi to achieve independence in 1947. This shared nationalist vision overcame regional and religious differences to create a sovereign India. Similarly, the chapter mentions the anti-apartheid movement in South Africa, where nationalism galvanised Black South Africans and their allies to overthrow racial oppression, leading to a democratic state in 1994 under Nelson Mandela.
Dividing and Generating Conflict: Conversely, nationalism can divide societies and spark bitterness. The partition of India in 1947, while a result of nationalist aspirations, led to communal violence between Hindus and Muslims, causing millions of deaths and displacements as India and Pakistan were formed. The chapter also cites the example of Nazi Germany, where extreme nationalism fueled aggressive expansionism and the Holocaust, creating widespread conflict and suffering during World War II. These examples illustrate how nationalism’s emphasis on a singular identity can exclude or marginalise groups, leading to division and hostility.
4. A stated, there is no single factor, descent, language, religion, or ethnicity, universally defines nationalism worldwide, as the basis of national identity varies across contexts. While these elements often contribute to nationalist sentiments, they are not consistently present in all cases. For instance, descent (shared ancestry) is significant in some nations, like Japan, where a sense of ethnic homogeneity strengthens national identity, but it is less relevant in diverse nations like the United States, where citizenship is based on civic values rather than common ancestry. Language can unify, as seen in Germany, where the German language was a key factor in 19th-century unification, but it is not universal. India, with its multitude of languages, fosters nationalism through shared history and anti-colonial struggle rather than linguistic unity. Religion may play a role, as in Pakistan, founded as a Muslim homeland, but secular nations like France prioritise civic principles over religious identity.
Ethnicity often shapes nationalism, as with the Serbs in the former Yugoslavia, but multi-ethnic nations like Switzerland rely on shared political institutions. The chapter emphasises that nationalism is context-specific, drawing on different combinations of these factors, and no single criterion universally applies, making it a flexible and diverse phenomenon.
5. There are several factors that foster nationalist feelings, often rooted in shared experiences or aspirations:
- Shared History and Culture: A common historical narrative or cultural heritage can ignite nationalism. One of the examples is Italy’s unification in the 19th century, where figures like Giuseppe Mazzini invoked shared Roman history and cultural traditions to unite disparate states into a single nation.
- Anti-Colonial Struggles: Resistance to foreign rule often fuels nationalism. In India, the struggle against British colonialism, marked by events like the Revolt of 1857 and the Quit India Movement, fostered a collective national identity across diverse groups, culminating in independence in 1947.
- Language and Literature: Linguistic unity or literary movements can strengthen nationalist sentiments. The chapter mentions the role of the German Romantic movement, where writers like Johann Wolfgang von Goethe and philosophers like Johann Gottfried Herder emphasised the German language and folk traditions, contributing to German nationalism.
- External Threats: Perceived threats from outsiders can unify a group. The chapter references the French Revolution, where external monarchies’ attempts to crush the revolution rallied French citizens around a nationalist cause, strengthening the idea of a French nation.
These examples show how diverse factors—historical, political, cultural, and external—combine to evoke nationalist feelings, varying by context.
6. Democracies are better equipped than authoritarian governments to manage conflicting nationalist aspirations due to their participatory and inclusive nature. Democracies provide mechanisms like elections, federal structures, and freedom of expression, allowing diverse groups to voice their aspirations and negotiate solutions. For instance, India’s democratic framework accommodates regional nationalist movements, such as those in Tamil Nadu or Punjab, through federalism, linguistic states, and political dialogue, reducing secessionist tendencies. The chapter notes that democratic institutions enable power-sharing, as seen in Canada, where Quebec’s French-speaking population’s nationalist demands are addressed through autonomy within a federal system, preventing violent conflict.
In contrast, authoritarian regimes often suppress nationalist aspirations, leading to resentment and rebellion. The chapter cites the example of Yugoslavia under authoritarian rule, where ethnic nationalist aspirations (e.g., among Serbs, Croats, and Bosnians) were repressed, contributing to violent disintegration in the 1990s. Authoritarian governments lack the flexibility to accommodate diverse identities, often resorting to force, which escalates conflicts. Democracies, by offering legitimate channels for dialogue and representation, can defuse tensions and integrate conflicting nationalist groups into the national framework, making them more effective in managing such challenges.
7. There are several limitations of nationalism, which, while a powerful force, can have negative consequences:
- Exclusion and Intolerance: Nationalism often defines an “us” versus “them,” marginalising minorities or outsiders. For references, Nazi Germany, where extreme nationalism led to the persecution of Jews and other groups, illustrating how nationalism can foster xenophobia and intolerance.
- Conflict and Violence: By prioritising one nation’s interests, nationalism can spark conflicts with others. We can see the India-Pakistan partition, where competing nationalist visions resulted in communal violence and ongoing border disputes.
- Suppression of Internal Diversity: Nationalism may suppress internal diversity to enforce a singular identity. In Turkey, Kurdish cultural and political aspirations have been curtailed in the name of Turkish nationalism, leading to unrest.
- Potential for Authoritarianism: Nationalism can be manipulated by leaders to justify authoritarianism. It implies that exaggerated nationalist rhetoric, as seen in some historical regimes, can undermine democratic freedoms by demanding unquestioned loyalty.
These limitations show that while nationalism can unite, it also risks division, exclusion, and conflict if not tempered by inclusivity and respect for diversity.
Download NCERT Solutions Class 11 Political Science Political Theory Chapter 7 Nationalism
You can also download the NCERT solutions for Class 11 Political Theory Chapter 7: Nationalism. We have given the free PDF for students below.
Also Read:
- NCERT Class 11 Understanding Society Chapter 3: Environment and Society Solutions (Free PDF)
- NCERT Class 11 Understanding Society Chapter 2: Social Change and Social Order in Rural and Urban Society Solutions (Free PDF)
Download NCERT Solutions of all Chapters of Class 11 Sociology Introducing Sociology here:
Related Reads
For more topics, follow LeverageEdu NCERT Study Material today!
