One app for all your study abroad needs
Chapter 9: Constitution as a Living Document from the NCERT textbook Indian Constitution at Work explores why the Indian Constitution remains relevant despite being over 69 years old. It explains how the Constitution adapts to changing societal needs through amendments, judicial interpretations, and political practices while maintaining its core principles. The chapter discusses the balance between flexibility and rigidity, the amendment process under Article 368, the significance of the basic structure doctrine, and the judiciary’s role in evolving the Constitution. These notes provide a clear and concise summary for Class 11 students for revision and exam preparation.
Table of Contents
- 1 Why is the Constitution a Living Document?
- 2 Key Features of the Constitution as a Living Document
- 3 Importance of the Constitution as a Living Document
- 4 The Amendment Process in India
- 5 Contents of Amendments
- 6 Basic Structure and Evolution of the Constitution
- 7 Maturity of Political Leadership
- 8 Important Definitions in NCERT Class 11 Political Science Indian Constitution at Work Chapter 9: Constitution as a Living Document
- 9 FAQs
Explore Notes of Class 11 Political Science: Indian Constitution at Work
Why is the Constitution a Living Document?
The Indian Constitution, adopted on 26 November 1949 and implemented on 26 January 1950, is called a living document because it adapts to societal changes without losing its core framework. Unlike static constitutions rewritten frequently, like the Soviet Union’s four constitutions in 74 years, India’s Constitution remains robust due to its ability to accommodate modifications through amendments, flexible judicial interpretations, and political practices. This adaptability ensures it addresses contemporary challenges while preserving fundamental principles like democracy and federalism.
Key Features of the Constitution as a Living Document
The Constitution balances flexibility (openness to change) and rigidity (resistance to unnecessary changes) to remain relevant. Here are the key features:
- Amendability: Provisions can be changed via Article 368, allowing adaptation to new societal needs.
- Flexible and Rigid Elements: Some articles require only a simple majority for amendment, while others need a special majority or state consent.
- Judicial Interpretations: Courts, especially the Supreme Court, evolve the Constitution’s meaning, e.g., expanding reservation policies or the right to life.
- Basic Structure Doctrine: Established in the Kesavananda Bharati case (1973), it protects core principles like democracy from amendments.
- Political Consensus: Amendments like the anti-defection law (52nd Amendment) reflect agreement among parties to address political issues.
Importance of the Constitution as a Living Document
The Constitution’s adaptability ensures it remains a dynamic framework for democratic governance. It responds to societal aspirations, like extending reservations for scheduled castes and tribes, while protecting core values. The judiciary’s role, through rulings like Kesavananda Bharati, safeguards democracy by limiting Parliament’s amendment powers. Political practices, such as coalition politics, further shape its application, making it a respected and durable document that balances change with stability.
The Amendment Process in India
The Indian Constitution, under Article 368, provides a structured amendment process to balance flexibility and rigidity. Some articles can be amended by a simple majority, like ordinary laws, while others require a special majority (two-thirds of members present and voting, plus half the total strength of each House). Federal provisions, like those affecting state powers, need ratification by half the state legislatures. Amendments are initiated only in Parliament, require no external commission or referendum, and the President cannot refuse assent. This process ensures broad consensus while empowering elected representatives.
Here are the key Aspects of the Amendment Process:
- Simple Majority: For minor changes, e.g., salaries of judges.
- Special Majority: Two-thirds of members present and voting, plus half the total strength of each House, e.g., for fundamental rights amendments.
- State Ratification: Required for federal provisions, ensuring state participation.
- Examples: The 52nd Amendment (1985) introduced the anti-defection law, and the 61st Amendment (1989) lowered the voting age to 18.
- Limitations: The basic structure doctrine (Kesavananda Bharati, 1973) prevents amendments that violate core principles.
Contents of Amendments
Over 106 amendments in 74 years (by 2024) address various needs. Some of the contents of Amendments are:
- Technical Amendments: Clarifications or minor changes, e.g., raising High Court judges’ retirement age (15th Amendment) or extending SC/ST reservations every ten years.
- Clarifying Interpretations: Amendments to resolve judiciary-Parliament conflicts, especially in 1970–75, over fundamental rights and property rights.
- Consensus-Based Amendments: Post-1984 amendments, like the 73rd and 74th (1992) for local governance, reflect political agreement.
- Controversial Amendments: The 38th, 39th, and 42nd Amendments (1975–76) during the Emergency were contentious, attempting to override judicial rulings and expand parliamentary power. The 43rd and 44th Amendments (1977–78) reversed many of these changes.
Also Read:
- NCERT Solutions Class 11 Political Science: Political Theory Chapter 7 Nationalism (Free PDF)
- NCERT Class 11 Political Science Political Theory: Chapter 2 Freedom Solutions (Free PDF)
Basic Structure and Evolution of the Constitution
The basic structure doctrine, established in the Kesavananda Bharati case (1973), is a judicial innovation that limits Parliament’s amendment powers. It protects core features like democracy, secularism, and federalism, ensuring the Constitution’s essence remains intact. The judiciary’s rulings, such as on reservations (50% cap) and the creamy layer exclusion for OBCs, have informally amended the Constitution by interpreting provisions like the right to education and life.
Some of the key judicial contributions are:
- Basic Structure Doctrine: Sets limits on amendments, balancing flexibility and rigidity.
- Expanded Rights: Interpretations of Article 21 include rights to education and privacy.
- Judicial Review: Ensures laws align with the Constitution’s spirit, as seen in the Minerva Mills case (1980).
Maturity of Political Leadership
The acceptance of the basic structure doctrine by Parliament and political parties post-1973 reflects mature leadership. Despite initial conflicts, especially during the Emergency (1975–77), the 43rd and 44th Amendments corrected controversial changes, showing respect for the Constitution’s vision of individual dignity, equality, and unity, as articulated by leaders like Nehru.
Important Definitions in NCERT Class 11 Political Science Indian Constitution at Work Chapter 9: Constitution as a Living Document
This section clarifies key terms of this chapter for revision:
- Living Document: A constitution that adapts to changing societal needs through amendments, judicial rulings, and political practices.
- Article 368: The constitutional provision detailing the amendment process, requiring special majorities and sometimes state ratification.
- Basic Structure Doctrine: A judicial principle (Kesavananda Bharati, 1973) protecting core constitutional features from amendments.
- Special Majority: Two-thirds of members present and voting, plus half the total strength of each House, required for most amendments.
- Judicial Review: The judiciary’s power to ensure laws align with the Constitution, shaping its evolution.
Explore Notes of Class 11 Political Science: Political Theory
Download the Solutions of Other Chapters of Class 11 Political Science: Indian Constitution at Work
Also Read:
- NCERT Class 11 Political Science Chapter 4 Political Theory: Social Justice Solutions (Free PDF)
- NCERT Class 11 Political Science Political Theory: Chapter 2 Freedom Solutions (Free PDF)
Related Reads
Explore Notes of Other Subjects of NCERT Class 11
FAQs
It adapts to societal changes through amendments, judicial rulings, and political practices, making it a living document.
It outlines the amendment process, requiring simple or special majorities and state ratification for certain provisions.
Established in the Kesavananda Bharati case (1973), it prevents amendments that violate core principles like democracy and secularism.
Over 106 amendments in 74 years address technical clarifications, judicial conflicts, and political consensus to meet evolving societal needs.
Through rulings like those on reservations and the right to life, the judiciary interprets provisions to align with contemporary needs.
For NCERT study material, follow NCERT Notes and Solutions Class 11 Political Science by Leverage Edu now.
